Your website should be your hardest-working employee, answering questions, capturing leads, and making the right impression 24/7. But for many business owners, it’s quietly underperforming.
It might look fine on the surface. But if you’re not seeing results, no consistent enquiries, no growing database, no real connection with your audience… something’s not quite right.
Here are seven website red flags that suggest your site might be costing you more opportunities than it’s creating. If you’re overdue for a small business website audit, this is your starting point.
1. No Clear Calls-to-Action
What do you want your visitors to do next?
If your site doesn’t clearly guide users “Download this”, “Book a call”, “Join the list” – you’re likely losing leads. A good website performance tip is to ensure every page includes an action step, not just your homepage.
Confusing navigation or buried CTAs don’t just frustrate users, they end the conversation before it even starts.
Tip:
Check your homepage, service pages, and blog posts. Are the next steps obvious, enticing, and easy to take?
2. Slow Load Times or Poor Mobile Responsiveness
Over 60% of web traffic now comes from mobile devices. If your website is sluggish or hard to navigate on a phone, you’re not just annoying your audience, you’re being penalised by search engines, too.
A few seconds’ delay is all it takes to lose a visitor.
Tip:
Use tools like PageSpeed Insights to test load time, and review your mobile layout. This is one of the quickest wins in any small business website audit.
3. Outdated Design or Unclear Brand Messaging
If your site looks like it was built in 2014, or worse, doesn’t sound like your brand anymore, it’s working against you.
Your website is often your first impression. If it’s cluttered, inconsistent, or visually off-brand, you may be losing credibility before the conversation even starts.
Likewise, if it’s not immediately clear who you help, what you offer, and why it matters, you’re creating friction. And friction costs conversions.
Tip:
Ask someone unfamiliar with your business to visit your site. Can they explain what you do after 10 seconds?
4. No Lead Capture or Conversion Tools
Even if your website gets visitors, what happens next?
If you don’t have mechanisms in place to collect email addresses, offer free resources, or book calls, your website isn’t working as hard as it could.
Think beyond the contact page. Consider simple, helpful tools like:
- Free downloads or checklists
- Newsletter signups
- “Get a quote” or “Ask a question” forms
- Pop-ups (used sparingly) or sticky headers with offers
Tip:
A lead doesn’t have to be a sale. It’s just a way to continue the conversation, so make that easy.
5. Missing SEO Basics
You don’t need to be an SEO guru, but a few foundational elements go a long way:
- Are your pages using clear headings (H1, H2)?
- Do your images have alt tags?
- Are your page titles and meta descriptions intentional and unique?
- Are you linking between relevant pages?
If not, Google may be ignoring your site, and that means your ideal clients might be, too.
Tip:
SEO isn’t just about ranking, it’s about being findable. These website performance tips are the technical backbone of visibility.
6. No Regular Content Updates
When was the last time you added something new?
A regularly updated blog, recent case studies, or fresh news tells your audience (and search engines) that your business is active, relevant, and invested.
If the last blog post on your site is from 2021, it can raise trust issues, even if your business is thriving behind the scenes.
Tip:
Add just one meaningful piece of content a month. Answer a client question, share a story, or post a recent win.
7. You’re Not Tracking Performance
You can’t improve what you don’t measure.
If you’re not reviewing analytics, page traffic, bounce rates, conversion paths, you’re making decisions in the dark.
At Oracle Tree, we often see clients surprised by what their data reveals: blog posts bringing in unexpected traffic, high-exit pages, or drop-off points in their funnel.
Tip:
Use Google Analytics and basic reporting dashboards. A simple review every month can help you spot issues early and optimise what’s working.
Your Website Should Be Pulling Its Weight, Not Just Looking Pretty
If you spotted a few red flags here, you’re not alone. Most small business websites grow in fits and starts, and sometimes they need a fresh eye to get back on track.
A great website isn’t built once and forgotten. It’s shaped over time, aligned with your brand, your customer journey, and your goals.
And if you’re not sure where to start?
Download our free Quick Website Health Checklist, it’s a simple, practical guide to help you assess where your site stands right now, and what to fix first. No jargon, just clarity.
Because your website should work as hard as you do.
Want More Like This?
What is SEO, and why should you optimise your website?
Website marketing is *STILL* an integral part of a brand’s digital footprint!
